[hylee]

The V1's noise levels were a little higher than I would've liked, especially in shadows and sky. The noise isn't nearly as bad as the Olympus C-50Z, but not as smooth as the Canon S50, either.

I found the photo quality to be inferior to the F717 and Canon G3/S50 for two reasons: noise and rather drab colors (turning up the saturation helps somewhat with that). Redeye was a problem as well, at least in my standard test. The camera body, too large to be pocket-sized, has a poorly placed optical viewfinder,no diopter correction knob, and a pop-up flash that gets in the way when in use. The battery life on the V1 is much worse than the competition, and the higher capacity Memory Stick Pro cards are nearly four times the cost of equivalent CompactFlash cards.

以上是 copy 自 http://www.dcresource.com/reviews/sony/dsc_v1-review/index.shtml

(作者在測試 Sony v1 後認為 Sony V1 的相片質素比唔上 F717 同埋 CanonG3, Canon S50 , 相片 noise level 嚴重, red eye reduction 用左都有紅眼情況出現.)

我睇完以以的評論同埋佢將同一/較高規格的DC (Canon G5 和 D60) 的相片比較, 癹覺似乎 Sony V1 的相片質素都係冇我自己本來想象中咁好 (Sony v1 的相片似乎比較 G5 多出很多 noise. http://www.dcresource.com/specials/G5_vs_V1/index.shtml)

有幾個問題係想請教各位 Sony V1 的用家...

Sony V1 是否真的有以上的專業評論中所指出的問題?
相片真的有noise level (尤其在較高的 ISO settings)是否真的很嚴重嗎?
Sony V1 相片質素真的比唔上400 萬象素的 Canon G3 ?
其實如果 Overall 來說, Sony V1 的相片質素掂唔掂?
各位Sony V1 用緊的朋友推唔推薦我買呢部 Sony V1呢?

Thanks

[ak47ml]

第一, 在大ISO的情況下, Noice 比較多, 是事實, 但紅眼, 我就冇碰過! 但有一可取之處就是輕和細. 雖然電可能冇其它Brand今好, 但我影足一日相 (大約40張),又Play又影,都未試過冇電. 但只供參考.

[zeusho]

我自己就Set緊ISO100來影，好多機到高ISO都會有好多Noise，如果你真係要用高ISO去影，而又有一定的要求，不如買300D郼一類機會好一點。

[Neworld]

我自己就Set緊ISO100來影，好多機到高ISO都會有好多Noise <----同意 Zeusho 的說法 ....

紅眼, 我就冇碰過!<-----我影左成半年都未碰過