DCFever.com

patrick2968 · 註冊: 2005-04-12 上載我的肖像

SIGMA & TARMON 18-200MM DC LENS WHICH ONE IS GOOD.

peterchan04 · 註冊: 2004-11-27 上載我的肖像

tamron 個枝係 XR
sigma 個枝吾係 EX

jormankiu · 註冊: 2003-12-02 上載我的肖像

So does that mean the Tamron one is better?

ken_chan · 註冊: 2005-02-28 上載我的肖像

SIGMA better and cheaper than TAMRON .
if you must buy either one. SIGMA la.
but the photo quality is not so good.

YCIS200 · 註冊: 2005-01-01 上載我的肖像

which is better ?

Sigma ?
Tamron ?
you ?

Think, think hard and you may not ask again .......

zkwok · 註冊: 2005-04-17 上載我的肖像

I have used the Tamron 18-200. It's color is quite good and optics is good at 18-120mm, acceptable over 120mm.
Someone said Sigma 18-200 is better but it's focus length is only around 160mm. So compare shapeness of tele side of Sigma 160mm with Tamron 200mm is not fair.
If need true 18-200mmm, only Tamron can give you. Otherwise, go for the Sigma 18-125mm. It's c/p value is higher than Sigma 18-200mm (actual 18-160mm only 35mm difference).