[hanny]

EF 24-70 2.8 L BETTER?
OR 24-105 F4L IS BETTER ?

I PREFER 24-105F4L IS BECASUE OF THE IS SYSTEM
BUT THE ONE F2.8L IS MORE CLEAR THAN THIS ONE OR NOT??
ANY IDEA??

[wtfgary]

Sorry Hanny, what do you mean by clear ?

I have used 24-70 F2.8 before and tried 24-105 F4 for short time. I personally prefer 24-70 F2.8 because of the following reasons (personal point of view):

- Similar price with bigger aperature
- IS in the range of 24-105 is not that important to me

Again, they are my own point of view.

[beancurdbean]

I think 24-105L IS better:
-- more tele to 105mm
-- 300g lighter
-- IS lower 3 shutter speed to use but F2.8 only rise 1 shutter speed
-- slightly cheaper

F2.8 of standard zoom not important to me, if I need narrow deep of field, I prefer use prime lens

24-105L IS has similar PQ as 24-70L at F4
If 24-70L at F2.8 is much worse than 24-105L IS at F4

[man1492]

http://www.photozone.de/8Reviews/index.html

[hanny]

thank you for your help