[yeeee]

想買部二手大机學影想。你覺得買Canon G5 定 KM A1好呢﹖請指教一下。

[samlch]

兩部都未用過,但單睇spec的話,論wide&zoom,ccd size,防震都係a1贏晒!!但好似話auto wb黎講,a1比較信唔過,要自己set.

[yeeee]

thanks samlch.
相片的質素最重要， 否則就無心机影了。

[intel875]

你budget 係幾多呀?
g5 同 a1 都ma ma 地

[dnamc2]

兩部機畫質差吾多啦

功能同速度就好大分別

如果你 buget 只可以買呢兩部機既二手價位既話

A1 啦

[kzescher]

用來學影相的話，A1啦．Funtion夠多，似單反機

[yeeee]

多謝你們的意見。 buget around $3000-4000. DSRL對我來說就太大投資了， 而且自知能力未到， 買都係side咗部机。

[comingup71]

I have these two DC before,
night shoot, A1 is really bad with lots of noise & hot pixels and its AWB isn't good, u should always prepare white paper for CWB.
beside that, A1 is much more better than G5:
1)Pic: G5 is more colorful; A1's tone is more natural.(but most of people like pic is taken by G5)
2)Af: A1 is really fast
3)function: A1 get more than G5
4)Battery life: G5 is good; A1 is better,
5)handling: A1'grip is more big and more suitable in hand
6)G5's viewfinder is below 90%, A1 get over 200k EVF with 100% viewing.

Go for A1, if u just make a choice BTW G5 & A1.
but what about 5060?
another good choice.

[batman200401]

It is suggested NOT to buy anyone.

You will be disappointed as both G5 and A1 CANNOT meet general requirement:
G5 - unacceptable focus speed for indoor photo
A1 - very poor image quality or hot pixels

[S7000+A2]

我suggest你買G5,雖然對焦速度慢d! 但係你係將quality放在首位的話就一定要買G5喇! 因為我都係A2既前user, 部機既quality同埋白平衡真係唔係好得...所以我先放左佢轉機!

[giantpanda]

2手價G5平過A1約5百，photo quality應該係G5好d。
For buget around $3000-4000可以買到G5的全新水貨。

我未用過G5，但係我曾經用過A2一段短時間。
由於我係新手，我當初想買部DC當傻瓜機用兼學影相，但係買了A2回來之後，我乜都唔識SET，影出來的相質素唔多好，而且好似有對焦不準的問題，令我非常無瘾，結果我好快賣番出去，現在買了300D。
但係聽呢度d師兄講，如果識用呢部機的話可以影到好的相。
所以我認為，如果係新手的話，唔係太建議買A1或A2，因為唔可以即時影到滿意的相。

[fantasy1981hk]

下...唔係下話...
G5同A1畫質差唔多?
就算唔計長快門個陣...G5畫質都高過a1好多啦...
g5畫質算係5m dc中好好的...a1係mama地的..=_=|||
而長快門a1更加不用多說,開耐少少機己經係接受唔到...
g5就算15s快門都仲好清仲好利架.(iso50)
不過...如果a1係未熱之前既iso400係比g5既iso400好的..
我講短過1/2s快門....
其實兩部都係好機...不過畫質一定要g5多lo...

[dnamc2]

睇 dpreview 做出黎既測試..

兩部機既畫質同 noise 真係差吾多囉~~

但如果要計長時間曝光...咁我唸 A1 就真係差d喇

睇下自己係咪影親相都影夜景囉....如果係就 G5 啦....G2 仲好添 ^^

[T.L.Wong]

G5 Hand Carry 好D,如果初學攝影,可以隨時隨地影多D相,G5質素有保證。

[alexlamfamily]

I owned A1 & G5 before but I choose G5 for important event. Even if A1 has 28mm, I used G5 for any night shoot.

Finally, I sold A1 at 40% discount in Sep 2004. KM emphasized on powerful features but gave up image quality (out of focus or horrible hot pixels).