[tony_chow]

Sigma 24-70mm F2.8 EX DG MACRO
Tokina AT-X 287 PROSV AF 28-70mm f/2.8
請問各師兄，呢兩枝鏡那枝比較好？多謝

[MN56]

Tokina is better

[tony_chow]

thx^^

[Canasony]

點解唔係Sigma better 呢?

[老叟]

點解唔係二個都好呢??

[hkicpa]

Tarmon A09

[Bus Fans]

In terms of build quality:
Tokina better than Sigma.

In terms of sharpness:
They both more or less the same. But Tokina "seems to be" a little bit sharper since it shows higher contrast.

In terms of distortion control:
Sigma better than Tokina.

In terms of flare control:
Sigma better than Tokina.

In terms of colour retention:
Sigma warmer while Tokina cooler.

In terms of CA control:
Sigma better than Tokina.

In terms of close-up capability:
Sigma closer than Tokina.

The above conclusions were test by myself. Hope can help you.

However, I won't chose either of them but the Tamron 28-75/2.8 nowaday.

[西枝]

of course la...
"SP" "XR" & "Di (without II)"
the TOP class from Tamron

[ASSAB]

但 Tamron A09 唔太靚仔

唔知新出果支又點呢?

[nes]

Tokina 100 marco VS Tamron 90 marco
質感好似 Tokina 好Ｄ
有冇師兄試過

[nes]

Tokina 100 marco VS Tamron 90 marco
質感好似 Tokina 好Ｄ
有冇師兄試過