[Dericxhk]

我有朋友想買DSLR呀~~
佢想買中級機, 考慮緊5D 同 D200,
佢本身有幾枝NIKON舊鏡,
但又覺得5D 既FF好吸引,
如果價錢尚算不是問題的情況下,

請求各位講解一下兩部機的特性分別><!

[beancurdbean]

FF vs APS-C
3fps vs 5fps
12MP vs 10MP
$18800 vs $10000
low noise vs many noise
none vs dust /drop prove
Good DR vs weak DR
C vs N
similar AF accuary

If have nikon lense, think D200

[小班長ErikoB]

low noise vs many noise
none vs dust /drop prove
Good DR vs weak DR
------------------------------------------------------------------
d200 many noise???唔係ar???好公道ge比較

[老叟]

似乎5D高一線,個價巳經好吸引喎!!!!

[beancurdbean]

d200 many noise???唔係ar???好公道ge比較
-------------------------------------
唔係ar, noise方面, D200出名仲差過D70s, D70s又差過20D, 5D就好過20D, 客觀d好o咼

Conclusions in Dpreview:
D200 (Cons 反)
- Higher noise at ISO 1600 and 3200 than we would like, mostly in shadows
- High ISO noise reduction works but at the expense of detail
http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/nikond200/page31.asp

5D (Pros 正)
- Very low noise even at higher sensitivities
http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/canoneos5d/page32.asp

[Dericxhk]

咁看來真係5D 好好多咁WOR~~
希望佢會買5D啦, 其實一直都覺得5D好,
CANON D機由5D以上就真係正... 我自己用緊350D...唉!
後悔唔入NIKON...

[hanny]

about d200 nosie is something like a normally machine noise

but about 5d the noise controll is execellant

about iso 800 is nearly as a very good machine of iso 100

flame big nosie controll physical will good

but about the shutter feeling d200 is better

both are good but not depend on money 100% 5d

i have a friend fr 350d to d200 and finally 5d

i love 5d becasue i can useback the original length as flim machine

depth field are same as the long history of 135 film machine

[win3t]

5d囉

除非有品牌情結.呢個問題都好易做決定

FF既優勢唔係幾支過期舊鏡可以拉扯平

因為你都咁豪話錢唔係問題....係咪

[Dericxhk]

哈哈~~ 豪既唔係我~~
我係佢學生~~ 佢教書都搵唔少啦~~~
所以5d 對佢來講係肉痛lor~ 不過唔係買唔起...哈哈><!
我有錢都買5d, 果時做助手見到影婚禮d師父個個都5d~哈哈

[Rol]

If budget can afford, I support 5D, I want to play full frame too...

If budget is 10K, D200 is the best buying.

If rich, buy both -> dual system, wide on 5D, tele on D200, woo super strong

[Lam Martin]

婚禮攝影師用5d咁落本, 果間攝影公司都應該幾貴下. 金都大部份攝影公司d師傅都係d200, 30d架咋.

有budget就買5d啦, 單單係ff已經好過d200, 起碼d鏡唔會再要乘1.5先啦.

[kingkonghk]

====
婚禮攝影師用5d咁落本, 果間攝影公司都應該幾貴下. 金都大部份攝影公司d師傅都係d200, 30d架咋.
====

我見有d用f5同eos3

[terrylamnet]

大家公平d好wo!!
5d係FF當然係d，但係個價自然係高好多啦(差唔多一倍)，但對於noise方面係iso1600以下d200同5d差唔多一樣，你地唔好人講話多noise你地講，起碼用過見過先好講得唔得。
D200同30D比會正常D囉....，不過5D一定要買閃燈，因為5D無內閃!!!

[bikram]

If you use D200 and shooting under 35mm using the build in flash, you will not happy since there are some black corner at the bottom of the photos. So for D200 you finally will need to buy the external flash anyway.....

[lambertnh]

其實只要用大口徑 Zoom 落罩+ 內閃就通常都出事