[laukit]

各位師兄,

Hello!
小弟第一次買DSLR, 想購入Canon 550D, 主要用作影風景(和旅行用).
但不想用Kit Set鏡, 如果想從下列副鏡中算一款, 請問哪一款比較好?

Tamron SP AF 17-50mm F/2.8 XR Di II LD Aspherical [IF] (A16)
Tamron SP AF 17-50mm F/2.8 XR Di II VC (B005)
Sigma 17-70mm F2.8-4 DC MACRO OS HSM
Sigma 17-50mm F2.8 EX DC OS HSM

謝謝.

[Laza]

I would recommed Tamron SP AF 17-50mm F/2.8 XR Di II VC (B005).

Its predecessor, A16, has great reputation. Now upgraded to have Tamron's famous VC, this one should be even better.

[wllui]

"第一次買DSLR", 最好買防震
b005性價比高
sigma 17-50解像度高

不過點解冇唸過買原廠呢?
17-55 f2.8, 15-85
17-40 f4L , 24-105 L全都不錯

[basschan]

如果真係要簡....你四支最貴個支都4,5千.....
咁不如買支15-85同18-135好過.....
APSC 24-135 / 29-216點都比27-112 強.....
如果只計旅行用....
何況你講的副廠最係大得個一級光圈...用途唔大囉....
SIGMA 17-50/2.8 係好....但係....你一支鏡係唔係多少少遠攝會好多呢???

買支18-135+50.8 咁都好夠做....

[Terencexb]

我覺得若去旅行，可以買支Tamron AF18-270mm F/3.5-6.3 Di II VC LD Aspherical [IF] MACRO(B003) 仲好，一支天涯鏡包晒所有焦段。否則，買Kit set(18-135)。

[petercyc]

如果錢係主要考慮...A16 (防震對WIDE鏡來講無咁重要(相對長鏡), 一般情況都夠用) .

唔係就CANON 17-55 2.8/F (唔差得幾多錢)

[laukit]

多謝各位師兄意見,我會o係買之前再稔清楚.

唔好意思,有一個問題,其實一開始我稔o個4支鏡(都係f/2.8),
係因為睇到好多雜誌同網上forum講f/2.8比一般f/3.5-x.x Sharp好多好多,
所以先稔呢4支鏡.

* 其實f/2.8同f/3.5-x.x比較,對影風景同埋旅行影相係咪真係咁大分別?

如果f/2.8同f/3.5-x.x唔係真係咁大分別,咁真係好似樓上師兄講,我可以買支18-270mm.

請賜教.

[wllui]

Sigma 17-70mm F2.8-4 DC MACRO OS HSM: 只有最wide的17mm端有2.8, 一zoom就收光圏, 日間室外冇乜所謂, 但夜景室內你就知恆定光圏的好處, 即去到50mm時都仲係f/2.8的重要性

[shkp]

I also use 550 .. and LOVE to take photos for 風景(和旅行用).

BUY C10-22 la

[little-fish]

EITHER STICK TO KIT LEN(CHEAP 2ND HAND $500 ONLY)
OR BUY 10-22 FOR WIDE , 17-40 L F4, BOTH AROUND $5,XXX

[hunter21]

我會選CANON 15-85 OR B005

CANON 15-85 有USM 對焦快D,但要另外買HOOD,都成兩舊水同埋只有一年保養.

B005就光圈大D,有埋vc,室內唔用閃燈都無問題.係成成買有四年保.

兩支都建議買二手,抵玩好多.

[1Q84]

如果budget容許, 我都推支c15-85.
IS+USM係強勁組合, 焦距x1.6後為24-136, 非常適合旅行.
PQ唔算頂級, 但作為旅行天涯鏡無野投訴(除非ching你臂驚人, 可以帶幾支鏡去旅行).

冇錯, 佢最大問題係光圈唔夠大(最多得3.5), 但反正影風景好多時都要收光圈.
諗諗la !

[SunnyDevil]

Sigma 17-70mm F2.8-4 DC MACRO OS HSM-----good

[shkp]

TO laukit Ching ...

If you really use it on 影風景(和旅行用) ....

HIGHLY recommend using C10-22 with wider focal length and easy capture all you want ... I borrow C17-40 on the 旅行 but nearly do not use ...

For C10-22, 10 to 18mm very good on 風景 & 18 to 22mm very good for ppl on 旅行

[shkp]

10mm to 17mm 的 鏡頭 power ...

Other lens cannot give you la ...