[vng_01]

Which one should I pick?

[desmond_li]

視乎你的budget, 攝影用途~

[ZeroJKwok]

兩支都應該擁有，一支有較大景深，一支有較好機動性。買晒兩支都係差不多等於一支2.8 IS II 吧! 但係有兩支鏡喎，底!!!!!!

[jsklee]

"兩支都應該擁有，一支有較大景深，一支有較好機動性。買晒兩支都係差不多等於一支2.8 IS II 吧! 但係有兩支鏡喎，底!!!!!!"

Agree x 100000!!

[vng_01]

They both almost have same price so it won't be a budget issue if picking either one.

^_^

[desmond_li]

甚麼焦距配多大的光圈﹐要先知道用途如何﹐才知道甚麼是最適合, 既然沒說用途﹐講咩都係沒有意義~

[vng_01]

Yes, you are right. I may be "wanting' them rather than "needing" them.

[neo323]

Sigma CS內試影一幅....

[jsklee]

if you can't make up your mind, I highly recommend you to buy both of them (either first hand or second hand). After you use them for some time, you are able to know which one better suits your photo style and you can sell the other one in 2nd hand market. You won't lose much if you buy 2nd hand in the first instance.

[jimw]

i vote EF 70-200mm f/4L IS USM,
as its too heavy for the f2.8 one...

[ZeroJKwok]

我兩支都有借用過去影，影的都是晚會，燈光比較雜亂，我個人會覺得大光圈比用f/4L IS較易控制，而2.8L的色彩比較好點，只是重了些，所以我在用2.8L時，我是有用單腳架的；我也有用2.8L 去影人像，出來的成像，這個就真係不用比了.......。最後，我自己買了支70-200 f/2.8L。=)

[wesleyyau]

又冇budget 又冇講影咩題材 好難俾意見...
既然係咁... 好似我咁... 買哂小白兔同SSWIS... 返屋企先諗咩題材環境用邊支...
仲有喎... 70-200 2.8唔好買I代買II代啦...

[babababa]

我諗樓主係想比較F2.8無IS同F4有IS....
如果係影室外多嘅就光圈大小分別不大，反正都會收光圈（要淺景深除外），反而F4有IS同瑩石，成像仲會有保證...
如果室內e.g舞台表演嘅就難揀啲.....
不過F2.8仲有個好處係用到十字對焦，對焦會快啲.....

但係我最後會建議樓主買.....F2.8IS II，一步到位，唔使再煩!

[vng_01]

Thanks all.

Since I love to see all your comments, I want to tell you ... heehee! I just bought sold out my Canon EF 70-200 f/4L and bought Canon EF 70-200 f/2.8L.

I did lots of testing on my friend wedding. Oh man..... f/2.8 is for me so far..... I could taste it almost perfect.

The image is super sharp, but well..... for sure..... the lens with my Canon 60D is very heavy but I could still stand for it.

Wonderful lens! I love it.

But my back was tired for 2 days.... hahahahahahaha!!!!!

[Takura]

有錢 2.8 is ii
無錢 4 is