[Neva]

如果以質數以及實用性爲主的話，大家會選擇Canon的100mm f2.8L IS 還是EF 180mm f/3.5L

因爲一支有防震，而另一支無防震，但無防震果支的距離又好似會方便一D????

[rankinelo]

Personally I'll choose 180L, but most CHing will suggest 100L...

100L is much easier to use, but 180L can make you a macro expert once you mastered it

To me, 防震 is really useless in macro world... It can help you to take photo easier and more convenient, but not take better macro photos. So it really depends on what you need.

[Neva]

Thxs

[新手之手]

唔止防震, 而且解像度& 銳利度都係百微IS 優勝~~~~~~

[rankinelo]

新手之手CHing,

>>解像度& 銳利度

maybe 100L is better in terms of "heart"
but in terms of official MTF chart release, 180L beats 100L already

180L
http://www.usa.canon.com/consumer/controller?act=ModelInfoAct&fcategoryid=155&modelid=7324

100L
http://www.usa.canon.com/consumer/controller?act=ModelInfoAct&fcategoryid=155&modelid=19091

All in all, sharpness is only one of the criteria, 100L is more convenient and easier to carry than 180L. Therefore most CHing suggests 100L and it is also a correct choice

[MN56]

180L is one of the best macro lens for shooting butterfly if you can master it.

[rankinelo]

>>180L is one of the best macro lens for shooting butterfly if you can master it.

Very agree with CHing, just it is very difficult to master :D

[ACanonGuy]

With the 180L you pretty much need to use tripod as a default and best with live view 5x/10x manual focus. It doesn't give you the mobility as the 100L may have given you but there is always other trade-offs.

I love my 180L. It is one of the sharpest lens that Canon produced but as others mentioned it needs some times to use it effectively and efficiently.

If you are serious about Macro, need the extra focal length, and don't mind using it with tripod, go for the 180L. If you like Macro, like the mobility, like to double up as a portrait lens, the 100L is also a great lens.

[叮噹仔]

100mL 對影近野黎講, 係得心應手,
方便到極,
但對遠野就愛莫能助.

但180mL 就對遠野有幫助,
對一般既marco 拍攝手法,
可以包曬大部份既題材,
如果係有心機慢慢影每一張macro既師兄,
180L 係最好選攝既~

[新手之手]

rankinelo ching,

唔好意思.....小弟睇錯問題.....心急睇錯以為問題係比較 "百微IS" & Sigma 180mm macro, 因為兩者價錢相近........


其實者各有優點......

百微IS >>
優點......新技術 Hybrid IS, 手持拍攝的成功率高, 不用擔心成像質素~~
缺點......拍攝距離對拍攝昆蟲(打蝶尤甚), 擔心會打草驚蛇~~

百微IS >>
優點......拍攝距離...0.5倍放大距離約0.66M, 有利於打蝶~~
缺點......180mm 或 288mm (APS-C 機) 手持拍攝可能憂慮功敗垂成~~

百微IS 優點 = 180mm 缺點
180mm 優點 = 百微IS 缺點

的確難於取捨, 不過小弟可能會投 "百微IS" 一票, 因為兩者價錢相距甚多, 亦因為玩masro只是小弟攝影興趣中的其中一個, 但若勁喜歡打蝶或專職生態拍攝人士則例外~~~~~

[laupcqc]

150mm f/2.8!

[step1]

我有買一枝100L鏡,
以受歡迎來講,應該係100L
因為100L間間鋪都冇貨,要訂,一番貨好快就冇晒,
而180L個隻好似間間都有現貨,
所以我估100L多人買多人用,
多人買的一般性價比比較高.