[大食懶豬仔飽]

1. Canon Powershot Pro 1
2. Konica Minolta DiMAGE A2
3. Nikon Coolpix 8700

佢地有咩優點同缺點呢?

平均來講, 邊部好d?

[mr.unknown]

我用緊A1, 如果A2 同A1差別不大的話, 個人覺得有以下優點同缺點:-

(優)
- AS
- Function 全面
- Flexible Forcus Point
- 機械變焦
- 按鈕就手

(缺)
- 長時間曝光noise 大
- LCD 質數差
- 無輔助對焦燈
- 28mm 變形幾大

[darrens]

Best lens, Powershot Pro 1 with L lens that is the best prosumer lens
power consumption with BP511/512 is very good
Canon E-TTL flash, 28-200 manual zoom lens
much better than G5
noise control with A2, coolpix 8700 may not be acceptable during low light and full dark conditions
zoom ring for A2 is good
but no improvment with Minolta GT-Lens make it's 8mp A2 not attractive
but zoom ring for 8700 is too much like novice DC feel....I wonder why Nikon just use manual zoom ring in DSLR and Nikon accessories is a bit expensive
In general, if picutre sample for Powershot Pro 1 is good,
then go ahead buy powershot Pro 1

[darrens]

Best lens, Powershot Pro 1 with L lens that is the best prosumer lens
power consumption with BP511/512 is very good
Canon E-TTL flash, 28-200 manual zoom lens
much better than G5
noise control with A2, coolpix 8700 may not be acceptable during low light and full dark conditions
zoom ring for A2 is good
but no improvment with Minolta GT-Lens make it's 8mp A2 not attractive
but zoom ring for 8700 is too much like novice DC feel....I wonder why Nikon just use manual zoom ring in DSLR and Nikon accessories is a bit expensive
In general, if picutre sample for Powershot Pro 1 is good,
then go ahead buy powershot Pro 1

[Elliott]

>>Best lens, Powershot Pro 1 with L lens that is the best prosumer lens
I think it is better to wait some impersonal testing results before you draw the above argument.
Even if best lens in SLR does not mean it must be the best in DC. Right?

>>Canon E-TTL flash, 28-200 manual zoom lens
Please beware that Pro1 has zoom ring control, but it is electronic linked not mechanical linked.

[gapman]

If you ask this question in this web, most people said Canon Pro 1 ! Believe it or not ............................................. !

[chu_ka_man]

各位施住:
L Lens 和 ED Lens 係有用,但係CCD 夠唔夠力都係問題.
你Zoom 到去200mm , 一定手震! 有550EX 點光都冇用?
睇定D先 , 我用Canon G3 加 Canon 1x 1.75 lens .都夠玩啦.
不過 , 要3選1的話, 我選Coolpix 8700.因為Nikko數碼的色 ,
好準不太誇, 有力D ......
Man

[AhYin]

我用緊5700, 個人覺得有以下優點同缺點:-

優點:
外形正，手感好
唔太重
8x zoom
good noise control
3mm微距
色夠真
測光準
LCD可扭
電子觀景器表現出色
RAW mode 拍照，方便後期編輯
用電量可以接受
對焦就冇d人講到咁慢

缺點:
唔夠WIDE
功能選用上較麻煩, 要開menu
鏡頭隔離D制要一段時間先會習慣
黑暗and長距對焦slow
晚上對焦可能要電筒(人像)
LCD mon 細左少少
配件真系好貴

[GUMGUM]

Yes, L lens is not a must. Many things can affect the image quality.
We need to wait for the release day of Pro 1 and see whether it is good or not.

A2 is a good prosumer DC, but the noise is little bit more but acceptable.
Remember to shut off the AS function and set ISO to 100 when taking photo which no need to use AS.

No comment on 8700 as I don't like Coolpix only (but I like D70 :)

[8989898]

點解唔受埋S牌的F828同埋O記的8080玩呀???????
話哂都係同級同班嘛....(F牌仲留梗級 = =" )

一般的資料比較大家可以參考呢到,相信唔少人都有睇過都唔定:
http://www.dcview.com.tw/article/newreadarticle.asp?id=2495

要比較呢幾部野,並不是易事,首先GE係五家都係DC業界的大牌子
技術和水平都係業界的龍頭
產品質素當然有返咁上下水平,要完全測試比較出是相當困難
其次五部機都各有其獨特的優勢,好似828的蔡斯鏡,4色CCD
PRO1的L鏡和反轉CCD;A2的AS系統和90幾萬像素的EVF;8700的ED鏡等等等等...

我個人用緊A2,感覺比A1的畫質好左唔少,鏡頭的解像力也比之前的好D...
但我睇過五部機的Samples覺得A2仲係差少少,解像力和銳利度最好係S牌,話哂蔡斯鏡喎,但係D色就有D唔自然,唔知係咪四色CCD的關係...
功能唔使多講A1有GE A2都有,只係快門同廣域對焦點仲有A/D轉換比A1差左D,其他都係A1之上又或者係具相同水平...

[Elliott]

>>想問下大家點睇,5700鏡頭同8700鏡頭係唔係同一枝鏡呢？？？？？
應該係... 你睇佢外形都冇乜大改動 應該大部分spec會同5700差無幾... 而最大改進都應該會係 加左對焦輔助燈 同 Nikon claim 8700既AF speed 會快左... 以解決5700既最大"敝"病

[大食懶豬仔飽]

push

[~Bee~]

A2 出左陣又出A3!!!
唔係丫~~

[irving]

要既就買 p記 LC1 啦, 呢3部 800萬都只有手動對焦

[crazyleaf]

下面係PRO1同8700係同一環境下影0既SAMPLE
(因為作者既失誤, 8700部份相用左"basic" image quality setting去影)

http://www.dcresource.com/reviews/canon/powershot_pro1-review/gallery.shtml
http://www.dcresource.com/reviews/nikon/coolpix8700-review/gallery.shtml
OM 8080 SAMPLE
唔知係機0既問題定人0既問題, D相都幾BLUR下, 得女仔果張好好
http://w3.dpgallery.com/resource/olympus_c8080wz/samples/