[stupid_idiot]

Dear big brothers,

I had took some photos with my friend this afternoon. Please have a look to see if you can figure out which one is by Canon and which is by Pentax. All the photos are set to the same shutter speed, same aperture and Sunny White Balance.

Equipment :
Pentax *istD + DA 16-45
Canon 300D 17-40L

http://www.fotop.net/chmak/pc_compare/

p.s. all the photos are direct from camera WITHOUT PS (Re-size only)

[philip5cf]

should it be A = canon?

[stupid_idiot]

NO!!!

A can be Canon or Pentax, I had mix them!!

[stupid_idiot]

philip5cf 大大，

你要遂一分出那一張是 Canon，那一張是 Pentax ！！

係米好好玩呢 ？？？

[philip5cf]

it still not that hard since cmos vs ccd, I do see that you're not set it in one number. but the clearer and blue should be P.

[philip5cf]

if I,m wrong, your 300D is very good! better then mine.

[stupid_idiot]

The 300D belongs to my friend while the Pentax is mine!!

Let's wait for more feedback.

[philip5cf]

under my point of VIEW! your pentax should be a stand out winner for using ccd, (before PS). if you using a D70 instead of pentax, if show instantly. that MY view. :--p

[EDCH]

Hi Mr. S.I.

Here is my guessing:

Pentax- 1a, 2a, 3b, 4b, 5a, 6a, 7b, 8a & 9a

The rest of them are 300D.

Waiting for your feed back

[EDCH]

Hi Mr. S.I.

Here is my guessing:

Pentax- 1a, 2a, 3b, 4b, 5a, 6a, 7b, 8a & 9a

The rest of them are 300D.

Waiting for your feed back

[stupid_idiot]

philip5cf 大大，

不要太早下判斷，最後的大眾意見可能係 Canon 勝出，我若有機會的話，都想試下 Pentax Vs Nikon。不過要先借到部 Nikon！！！

[阿▁▂㊣▂▁]

In my view,

Canon 300D 17-40L as Follows

1b, 2b ,3a, 4a, 5b, 6b, 7a, 8a, 9b


I Like 300D 's colour more then Pentax , is my answer Right ???

[philip5cf]

under the cmos weak point, it show quite normally the NON PS picture will look soft! since blue colour is the basic to make the picture look sharp. so it still, as least to me. I would be wrong. but by the book, or as my knowledge. I do thanks for telling me the true. whoever.

[stupid_idiot]

Will release the answer next Monday or Tuesday.

Meanwhile, I want to have more feed back.

[kkyy]

I know the answer, but difficult for readers to compare indeed.

You compress the photo to such a small size; different in-camera settings can affect a lot, say sharpness setting; one is shot in sRGB and the other in Adobe RGB.

In general, what I can see is 300D has a much better dynamic range shown in a consistent fashion. The shadows retain much more details.