[神金丸]

你地對 e 兩支鏡有乜 commend??????
如果用 nikkor 機, 係咪簡返 nikkor 嗰支好呢???

[ELIZABETH]

按我

[kenkong]

ELIZABETH兄，

個度話： About the vignetting in the Tokina 12mm shots, I screwed up and didn't twist the lens hood all the way so it wasn't locked in position. I don't expect to see vignetting with a properly attached lens hood.

會唔會將Nikon同Tokina的相倒轉了放！



神金丸兄，

我無用過支Nikkor 12-24mm但我有支 Tokina12-24，支Tokina背光時會有紫邊，而且支鏡好像有輕微偏紅，其它我都大致滿意。價錢只係支Nikkor的一半，算係足夠交代了！

[fdman]

why not consider Sigma 10-20 together,
最強的變形控制，比Nikon原廠更好，不過color/sharpness 不及nikon了
I'm using Sigma 10-20 now

[baddad]

I don't think it make any sense to make comparison because of the price difference.

[chantzekon]

價錢永遠係第一個考慮，原廠鏡值唔值貴一倍自己話la，有D值，有D副廠仲正。但這二支鏡比我揀佐原廠，因為 Wide angle lens 最重要唔變型，我對原廠有信心。

[nosliw]

試看看

http://www.kenrockwell.com/tech/digital-wide-zooms/comparison.htm

[hkwong1968]

http://www.dchome.net/viewthread.php?tid=219876

[cools]

Nikkor 12-24，變形得好勁(nikon wide angle一向唔得)
Tokina 12-24, 未用過，冇意見
Sigma 12-24, 接近冇變形, film 機都用得，但12mm有暗角，如用APS size CCD的DSLR就冇問題
Sigma 10-20, 未用過，冇意見
如果你要最好的色彩，等Carl Zeiss ZF出 wide angle la

[kenkong]

cools兄，

點解你話『nikon wide angle一向唔得』？願聞其詳，謝謝！

p.s.
以我所知，Nikkor 12-24mm f4 係第一支給APS size的super wide鏡。