[haha1969]

諗緊買邊部，大家比下意見.

[Tri-A]

What do you want? Picture quality - 5700, Feature and connectivity - 717.

[haha1969]

曬相質素要好，一機走天下，

[savingryan]

buy D-SLR.........

[ronald]

平心而論,
1, 256mb的MS貴或CF貴?
2, 5x or 8x 差別大不大?
3, 一機走天下的size, 你會否考慮?
4, ED鏡和蔡司鏡的效果一樣勁

717的夜貓好正, 外型殺食,

[chanraymond3]

Nikon 5700有8x光學變焦, 防手震及NR, 相質好, 比我會擇5700

[boloto]

其實兩部都各有所長, 本人未用過5700不能講出其優點, , 我用過coolpix 885, 775, 2000, 三部nikon機既同一決點係對焦好慢, 而相片質素我會覺得係電腦睇nikon 會好過sony, 但又唔可以話同sony相差好遠, 用707我就真係幾鍾意, 對焦極快,功能易用, 本身鋰電勁耐用, 夜攝極強, 又唔需要帶電筒, 而717功能仲強過707, 所以比我會選717

[Velsper]

要相質,兩者不相白仲
對焦要快準,5700被比了下去
論操作,個人比較喜歡717
顏色還原,小弟鍾情nikon
一機走天涯
小弟覺得5700應會合你要求:
35-280mm與顏色

[haha1969]

我見到717個樣，鏡頭大，身細，ja 手會唔會唔好控制?

[Velsper]

用兩隻手嘛 ^__^
制擺位小弟覺得唔錯

[CCCi]

You should go to look at the real picture quality. Carl Zeiss does not necessarily good on picture. Overall camera design is very important. Let me give you an example, Leica lens is also as famous as Carl Zeiss lens. Design outlook of Leica Digilux 1 and Panasonic DMC-LC5 is very similar, using same Leica lens. However, the picture quality is totally different.

Camera production is different from just electronics. It must combine the electronic technology and the understanding of photography. Electronic design is much easier in learning, but the art of photography is much more difficult to understand. Nikon has many many years experience in photography, while Sony has only a few years.

So, you must choose what you really want. To get fun on digital camera, pick Sony is ok. To get enjoyment of good picture, I would suggest you to choose Nikon CP5700.

Besides, pls go to get an actual feel of both camera. When to take the actual product up with your hands, you can definitely tell which one is designed for photography, which one is designed as digital product only.

[haha1969]

thanks for your reply first.

I had read the comment of dpreview. However, i was unable to make a decison. Ity seems tha t no one is perfect and 717 and np5700 should be the best among them.

The expensive battery box is one of my hesitation of not buying cp57000.

[alanlaw]

i am using 5700, i buy some spare enel1 instead of mb5700.


memory stick is expensive and make me hestitate to use sony.

[KennyLau]

I agreed with CCCi's points, you should go to hold the macines on hand to feel it ! Personally, i will prefer 5700 (as i am using) becos the machine holding on hand is much more balanced than 717.

[Jacky仔]

<<5700有8x光學變焦, 防手震及NR....>>
5700沒有防手震功能的唷....
Nikon的防手震鏡頭都有個"VR(Vibration Reduction)"字樣的 ^_^

比我會選5700, 無它, 一張1GB MD是1800元, 一張1GB的MS要六千幾元 :)