[spider2003]

我現在使用S45，想升級，但不知應買G5或是Coolpix5400好，請大家給我一點建議？

我還見到Coolpix5700，好勁呀！

[kintak]

I don't have both DC but have a chance to use them.

I think Nikon's 5400 & 5700 are strong in functions and specs, but not user-friendly enough. When I use them, I think they are quite slow in operation and I really don't like their LCDs, too small...

I have not use G5 but my company is using G3, nearly the same except the resolution. I think it is good in functions, quality, and usage. Except it is quite large, just like a big "brick"... But for me, I would choose Canon G5!

[老叟]

我就諗都唔使諗,直頭揀5400!!

[Terry168]

(1)功能類別: G5的大光圈與5400的廣角鏡, 熊掌魚翅, 各有所愛, 大光圈可以在室內, 商場, 黃昏配合低ISO及高快門, 非常好用. 廣角鏡在街道, 細空間場景, 建築物可大派用場, 影風景更能反映出個種氣魄.

(2)人像攝影方面: G5色彩鮮麗, 層次豐富, 膚色柔和漂亮, 給人的印象很深. 而5400色彩還原準確, 很接近人眼所見, 但顏色過於平庸, 缺少個種讓人眼前一亮的感覺.

(3)圖片質量: G5成果清晰, 畫面純淨, 細節豐富, 柔和艷麗. 圖質較”軟”. 5400成像銳利, 畫面明亮, 立體感強, 色彩真實, 圖質較”硬”.

我會選G5

[HWC]

諗都唔諗,揀 G5

[vkwtsui]

按我以前用過5700及G2的經驗，我一定選G5。當然，若已經有S45在手，換G5（4 x zoom, 5MP)恐怕不必了

[QIUYUN]

一定要買5400, 又輕又正又靚仔!
其實同vkwtsui 0既意見一樣, 你有S45, 仲換G5做0羊0者。我係你緊係揀nikon 5400啦。我依家用緊, 部機真係好pro, 去旅行果陣有28mm你話幾正呢。我見Terry168話5400顏色唔夠鮮艷, 我俾唔到你睇, D色真係鮮到暈 (不過張相係Professional級0既人影, 唔係我影0既), 只要ev under少少, 張相顏色就會好豐富0剌, 不過如果你無用開nikon機, 我俾心理準備你, 真係要0米一輪manuel book先至識用, D掣好鬼多好煩, 不過用熟0左就okay啦。

[chriscyho]

g5唔夠廣可以加廣角鏡,但光圈係咁大就咁大架喎.....

[buddyhk]

Dear all experts,

This has been a difficult question for me too, as I am now also considering whether to buy a Canon G5/Nikon 5400.
I am a Canon 135mm camera user. For G5, I can still use my 420 Ex flash. However, I heard that this model has been carrying so many negative comments about its focusing speed, and not much difference from G3, except for the slightly higher resolutions. If this is true,
I think I incline to choose Nikon 5400, of which its 28mm lens is more attractive to me (one of my Canon lens is 24/85mm, which I think is very useful in shooting travel pics. I love travelling a lot)

Regards,

Buddy

[pk0556pp]

你喜歡色彩鮮艷及功能全面的話就Ｇ５啦（不過個人覺得太鮮艶啦唔啱我）
喜歡廣角微距及忠於原色的話就ｃｐ５４００啦（欠决TTL閃燈功能，失望~）

[HWC]

If you have 420EX, you must choose Canon products. If you think that 35 mm is not wider enough, you can add a Raynox 0.66X. It is a very good wide lens for G5 with fully zoom. Don't think that a sharp photo is a professional class, sometimes, a sharp photo is an disadvantage.

[kintak]

just looking at the spec, I think Nikon 5400 is more attractive, but there is a big defect - performance...

According to the web site DPReview.com, 5400 is not too good in performance - slow in operation, low internal buffer makes the camera "lock up", totally unresponsive when writing images, and also slow AF...

Details can be check out here:
http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/nikoncp5400/page18.asp

[laputako]

How about I have a G2, is it worthwhile to buy a new G5 or 5400?
I think G2 is the best in the G Series.

[Rainbow_peter]

我用Coolpix 5400的, 因我全部都係用Nikon. 用閃燈都唔洗再買.
仲有28mm f2.8好正.