[lokman926]

CHing 們,

小弟想買紅圈遠攝, 會係室內影人,三支唔知揀邊支好...PLEASE ADVICE

1.70-200 F4 USM, 價錢好, 夠輕, 但唔知indoor 影人係唔係就算有燈冇IS都唔夠?
2. 70-200 F4 USM IS ...價錢仲OK ....不過IS 係唔係對indoor真係好咁多, 如果70-200 F2.8 會唔會解決到IS 問題?
3 70-200 F2.8 USM ..三支最貴, 如上...F2.8 足唔足夠 解決冇IS問題...PQ同小小白有冇分別?, 知道係重, 135lb 既男仔, 2,3個鐘頭既trip, 頂唔頂得順lei?

THANKS X 999999999999

[Ison]

2,3個鐘頭既trip, 頂唔頂得順lei? 好睇個人問題架喎.

[JSmith]

IS唔係用來解決光圈細問題，一樣還一樣。遠攝IS係好有用，光圈就視乎個人需要。如果係影影室內多，建議都係買有IS。重有支70-200 F2.8 IS，我諗你都唔會考慮。你個case，可能70-200 F4 IS會係最好。

[upatchow]

70-200 F4 IS 應該對你係講係最好

[ACanonGuy]

I had a 70-200mm f4 and switched to f2.8 IS. F2.8 without IS will be a pain since it is so heavy. Given the cost of f4 IS and f2.8 non-IS is very similar, I probably will go with f4 IS if I were to stay with that price range.

If you find yourself using tripod/monopod most of the time anyway, certainly go with f2.8 non-IS. If your camera body performs well under higher ISO with acceptable noise level (i.e. 5DM2), f4 may just be fine even in-door under low light other than missing the more drastic background blur with f2.8.

another consideration is with the newly announced 70-200mm f2.8 IS II, would it be easier to find a used legacy 70-200mm f2.8 IS with good price?

Hope this helps.

[Obi-Wan]

70-200 F4 USM IS <=== best PQ & light

Don't think 70-200 F2.8 nonIS or IS unless u are very strong. The heavy weight of 70-200 F2.8 will prevent u to bring this lens out frequently, so it would not be used after u have owned it for the first few months.

[checkylam]

大光圈唔係用黎補is的,當然大一級光圈,即可以快一級安全快門,快門快左係可以輔助到手震的問題,不過同時大光圈又影響左景深&散景。你先要攪清楚光圈,快門,iso 三者的關係先,每一個item亙相之間會有咩影響&你張相付出咩代價?唔係你遲下可能會問iso3200可唔可以彌補光圈不足&無is。
你講果3枝,我個人的話,無is果2枝我就唔揀,小小白is有4媛,始終易d保持安全快門,就算小白is得3級,但已經好好。小白non is本身都幾重下,無is的話,我老喇,一定唔得。so我只會係小白is & 小小白is度揀,final我揀小白is。

[reflexboy]

Quote<<<<<<<<<Don't think 70-200 F2.8 nonIS or IS unless u are very strong. The heavy weight of 70-200 F2.8 will prevent u to bring this lens out frequently, so it would not be used after u have owned it for the first few months.>>>>>>>>>>>>

That's the funnest bulls_h_i_t I've ever heard in my life! GJ Obi Wan!

[卍明仔卍]

70-200 無is 手持會有難度. <對我黎講,因為係viewfinder 睇出去已經無信心影到....

室內影人 姐係車可以到的地方重量應該吾太緊要.

咁有錢當然2.8 的is 但比我會睇定d等埋枝二代出..
因為景深一定2.8正,但睇d網上比較真係4l sharp過2.8l
http://www.the-digital-picture.com/Reviews/ISO-12233-Sample-Crops.aspx?Lens=103&Camera=453&Sample=0&FLIComp=0&APIComp=2&LensComp=404&CameraComp=453&SampleComp=0&FLI=0&API=3
我因為依個網買左70-200 4l is.....

[Obi-Wan]

reflexboy

"That's the funnest bulls_h_i_t I've ever heard in my life! GJ Obi Wan! " <=== This is because u have limited exposure to photography & your life is limited or your age is too young.

** As I don't have the talent to response ppl with limited EQ or IQ, my respone to you, Mr. reflexboy, will stop here **

Stop ruin this thread. Thanks~

[reflexboy]

You had shown us enough Obi Wan!
One f stop can really save you from hell to haven! The difference between holding at 1/30 and 1/60 is a very good example.
Photography is all about idea, equipment, skill and most importantly "PASSION"!!!!!!!! Passion kid!!!! Do u have it?
So, please don't post anything to mislead all readers. Especially the youngster here! My best regards!

[wow9]

小弟爛post 一篇, 唔嫌棄既話可以比樓主參考下:
http://www.dchome.net/viewthread.php?tid=796355

It is nothing near to a professional review or technical comparison, but just a journal written to share my feelings after a one day outshoot.

[reflexboy]

Sorry, just a quick reply. According to your post Obi Wan. It looks like you u agree with me! I m young! And what u had posted wasn't the funniest BS! And u have definatley something bigger and stronger right?

[william_lau]

70-200 2.8L is真係好鬼重，連埋部機的重量加埋一齊真係會打擊到攝影的passion架喎。 我玩過呢支鏡差不多半年（問人借），除咗開頭真係有passion去玩之外，後尾出去影相，一諗起呢支嘢重量就有啲怕怕。 你可以話我唔夠大隻、又可以話我個攝影之心唔夠堅定，但對於一個唔係用來做job搵食的人來講，負擔實在太重。 我相信就算用來做job的師兄，非必要都會避開呢個巨物。

就算只講畫質，小小白is亦優勝過佢，小白的優點就只剩2.8光圈，以現今相機高iso低噪與及小小白is中十分有用的is系統來講，可以話解決到快門的問題。

小白+機，舉起佢影四、五張相就要放低休息下，你又確保到唔會miss咗精彩的一刻咩？

當然，每人拍攝習慣唔同，我只係講出我作為用家的感受。

[reflexboy]

又想問下你呀william,你會唔會長hold你枝小小白is唔放低?定係你都會影幾張又放低要嘅時候再舉高?
快嘅快門只係用o黍防手震?對capture移動物件無幫助？
有得選擇,你會用較高iso定係較低iso?點解？
所有想得到嘅事物,一定都要有某程度嘅付出！正所謂no free lunch！
obi wan 有你呢個專幫佢清理佢啲糞便嘅朋友,實在係佢嘅福氣！