[andrewxi]

各位c兄 c姐會怎選擇?
Nikon AF-S VR Zoom-Nikkor 70-300mm f/4.5-5.6G IF-ED VS Nikon 80-200mm f/2.8D ED AF Zoom-Nikkor
這2支那一個比較好? 一支有VR, 一支有大光圈~! 都唔知選邊支好~! 個人比較手持多~~係唔係選有VR的比較好?

[plasticben]

80-200

[andrewxi]

如果80-200 無VR手持影人會唔震得好勁?
我試過龍仔支70-200無VR~手持影都有震既情況~特別係夜晚梗勁~!

[Obi-Wan]

optical quality, 80-200/2.8 (小黑, original Nikkor optics) is much much better than the 70-300mm VR (derived from Tamron optics)

Also 70-300mm is NOT quite suitable to "影人" because (1) ugly bokeh, (2) not narrow depth of field due to smaller aperature

[fwan67]

I've used both 70-300 and 80-200 and finally, I buy 80-200, image quality is totally different and can't compare.
problem of 80-200 is only heavy. For VR issue, you can overcome, by following
1. Using tripod
2. Using faster shutter, I usually using 200 or above
3. Physical training of your arm

:-)

[terencehonin]

Nikon VR 70-300mm

[onlyken]

70-300 VR 永遠做唔到 80-200 f2.8 既淺景深散景效果, 生為一個攝影人, 一世人, 一定要擁有一支大光圈鏡才不枉此生! 但如果論輕便, 一定係70-300佔優, 所以應該同時擁有依兩支鏡, 各有所長!

[andrewxi]

fwan67: 因小弟是新手, 所以haha~唔洗講都知我技術點la~哈哈~! 我想問一下, 在陽光好的環境下~! 快門放大~是不是就等於防手震? 因為我search過~ 1/40係唔係就係安全防手震既快門? 同埋係夜晚影人個時, 點樣可以解決無VR既情況下唔怕手震同個人動既話 >3<

terencehonin: 你d相好正 >3< 高手果然係高手~! 一睇唔中毒都無咩可能~!

onlyken: 如果2支都要有~咁可能係小黑5已經有晒~哈哈

[terencehonin]

有 VR 真係幫忙好大, 70-300 VR 係光源足夠的情況底下顏色 PQ 都好OKAY, 如果室內唔夠光, 則一定要有外閃.

影夜景, 就一定要有 Tripod (事先聲明) =P

[winnwong]

路過....咁728好定828好啲呢?

[vickyskkan1968]

想問一問各位ching LB5如不開VR時,相片質素好過LB3幾多呢?Thx.

[fwan67]

andrewxi : basically, I've forget the formula to calculate the shutter speed to prevent handshake. I always based on my experience. For shutter speed =40, it is good for my 17mm but never use for 200mm, you will always find a blurr image :-( quality are very bad.

I try not to have shutter speed below 200, under sunshine, you may try shutter up to 600 or even 1000 with polaizer, it will give you a very sharp image.

At the first day to use my lens, photo taken are more terrible than using a DC. At least after 2 months intensive training, I've overcome many difficulties before able to take a little bit good picture. Because different lens give you different feeling and effect.

Now I used this 80-200mm for more than one year. This lens is good for portrail, bird, animals and sport.

Lets enjoy photographing
:-)

[onlyken]

安全快門 = 1/ 焦距, e.g. 焦距 200mm => 安全快門=1/200s or above

[andrewxi]

Fwan: Thanks for share your experience to me. I need take more training for me frist. haha

Onlyken: Thanks.

[isheyau]

首先,要申報, 我兩支都有用,原因,跟本兩支用途都唔同!

80mm 人像, 深景深, 無得揀, 8-200, 因 PQ 同要 f2.8。
80mm 風景, 要細光圈, 長景深, f5.6 以上, 7-300 有VR, 可以用手影!

如果是移動主體 200mm ,大家話用8 -200, f2.8 , 1/250 定 7-300 , f5.6, S1/60, 要freeze 主体所以 80-200 S1/250會好Ｄ. 7-300 , S1/60 要玩 pan 鏡, S1/60點玩呀? 不個ISO 幫到手。

300mm 打雀, 無得揀 7-300, (飛雀例外, 要用384) 8-200無原廠增距鏡, 加副廠增距鏡(我用Tamron 1.4x) 8-200會差過 70-300唔加。
要注意, 好多時 7 -300 對唔到焦, 因 200mm f5.6 以下對焦會困難 (ISO 幫唔到), 8 -200 行f2.8 會怏夾準。

還有很多比較, 如Macro, 不能長講呀!

所以要睇影セ? 如不, 那會有 小黑五呢? <<< 我感覺小黑三D色濃個小黑五!!!!>>

我個人喜觀8-200多D, 如, 那會用上十年多!!!! 但真係好重呀！
希望幫到你