[kaidogg]

大家好
我覺得自己玩400D 已經玩到昇左 LEVEL
由超新手昇左上 初級組
400D 已經滿足唔到我 (先唔講LOW機都可以影到好靚相呢個理論 HEHE)

加上 我玩過朋友部 NIKON D3 發覺完全係另外一個世界
(我係 DIE HARD CANON FANS 唔好叫我轉 NIKON 呀)
於是決定換部高級機

5D MK II OR 1D MK III (2手)
由於兩者價錢差唔多 所以考慮呢兩部
1D MK III 個 LOOK 真係殺死人 不過又唔係 FF 喎

希望各CHING 可以 指點謎津

[ivanlee615]

大大要諗下自己用的相機用途吧

小弟會選5D2
因為不會常用連拍,不會再買EFS鏡

[kaidogg]

多數影 小朋友
已經有50.F1.4

唔係我果兩隻大小不良 我都唔會開始玩相機
而家開始學下影人像 MODEL 都仲係我個大女 OR 老婆多
連拍就嘛嘛地 因為400D 連拍都慢慢地 小影小影連拍


另想問問
5D MKII 個 VIEW FINDER (個眼仔，隊隻眼入去睇野果個位) 有冇 D3 個 咁大架?

[william_lau]

同D3比就唔知，但5D2個VF一定比400D大好多同光好多。

[JSmith]

1D Mark III 同FF 機一樣，唔可以用EF-S Lens
快速連拍對你冇義意，就唔好諗1D mark III。5D mark II已經夠玩

[bryanxhui]

.....師兄依家仲買1DIII 做咩呀. 除咗想買虛榮感之外. 你話係唔係.......!

[pongyee]

以影像質素來說，5D2 勝過 1D3。

[bb1032003]

For portrait, 5D II will be better than 1D3. Your 50 1.4 will be excellent for portrait on 5D II. Buy the 85 1.8 as well around $ 2600 value for money on 5D II.

[khadafy]

如果閣下真係要速度的話...咁就一定係1D mkIII 喇...
是5DmkII完全卑唔到你的........
至於畫質mkIII也是很好的,
比起400D當然強很多很多啦！

[lewealace]

of coz 5D M2 if not Nikon
definitely
unless you want the handling of 1- series and hardware (e.g Viewfinder, menu, body) or for 虛榮感
quality-wise 5D of coz much much better
Digic 4 with lastest spec.
2.1 MP
HD video( dunno if useful to you or you dun want)
low noise performance

and it's new ( not only the latest release of Canon, but also becaz if you buy 1DMark3,it is 2nd hand)

[Obi-Wan]

If u are NOT a pro,
buy 1D3 (APS-H) for speedy focusing and continue firing on sport
buy 5D2 (FF) for enlargement 80"X100"
buy 1Ds3 (FF) for speedy focusing and enlargement
if don't understand the above and have enough $, buy ALL of them

if want to take good photos of your girls, buy a good lens for your 400D and read more photobooks, practice more. I don't think 400D is much worst than 1D3, 5D2 for daily use


Enjoy photography, not just enjoy photographic equipment

[fish30d]

"Enjoy photography, not just enjoy photographic equipment "

Well said Obi-Wan. We must know what we want, then find the means to get it, not the other way round.

[william_lau]

我個friend個老細係有錢一族（即係我地一萬蚊對於佢來講係只係十蚊雞），佢想玩下相機，唔係好識影相但買左1Ds M2, 跟住出左M3買M3，L鏡差不多成套齊，後尾佢賣晒1系機，買左5d2，原因係話佢唔係好識用1系，太難喎。 XD

[csmarco]

kaidogg
其實我跟你亦有以上的煩惱.只不過我比你少了關於鏡頭的考慮思素.
我亦是一個死硬派的CANON FANS.先講一講我自己先啦.
我由上年五月初開始正式用單反開始,以前玩DC唔好計.
我第一部單反就係5D,跟住買多一部400D給仔仔,再買多一部G9給太太,
一人一部唔使爭,有時重可以交換用下,跟住就買左下列器材.
買400D的時候,其實450D已經有得買,但係我個人鍾愛CF卡多過SDHC卡,而且G9的電池,
又同400D一樣,可以共用,所以我毫不考慮就買左400D,至今亦無悔.
我第一支鏡係5D的KIT鏡,24-105L F4 IS USM,很好用.
再買就係70-200L F4 IS USM,原本想買70-200L F2.8 IS USM,
但係仔仔嫌支鏡實在太重,所以至會買70-200L F4 IS USM.
有次為左幫朋友的囡囡影生日相,由於拍攝地方太細,而且當日人數又多,
結果當日就買了一支17-40L F4 USM去影,不知不覺間就買齊了小三元.
仔仔去左觀塘職業訓練局讀攝影課程,佢想我買多支100-400L F4.5-5.6 IS USM給他,
結果總數我就買了4支L鏡,撫心自問,4支L鏡都令我好滿意,有買貴,冇買錯.
5D和400D都配埋直度,有直度個平衡感很好.我其實一點都不怕重,因為機重會定好多.
要玩夜攝,我就買埋580EX II和540EZ,540EZ係上網買易手的,六百元,好抵!
買埋原廠快門繩和曼富圖腳架,因為器材重,腳架唔敢買平野,深怕容易塌架引致大災難.
為左有次去一家三口去泰國玩,G9就配埋潛水殼,水底影珊瑚,真係好正!
用得多變焦鏡,又想試下定焦鏡的味道,就買左下列5支定焦鏡,次序如下:
100MM F2.8 MACRO USM(當時買嚟影下花草或昆蟲.)
50MM F1.4 USM(唔買50MM F1.8,係因為1.8對焦比較慢,而且係膠接環.
畫質兩鏡其實分別不大,但價錢就差左幾多.)
85MM F1.8 USM(呢支仔仔比較用得多,我真係好少用.)
28MM F1.8 USM(真係好用,但影人就較易變形,始終係28 Wide.)
35MM F2(呢支影景和影人都好正,影人冇咁易變形.)
全部配哂原廠遮光罩,有次貪平,買左個副廠遮光罩給28MM F1.8 USM用,不夠一星期,
已經頂唔順個接位實在太緊,而且竟然唔可以反轉裝,好阻地方,立即買返個原廠,立即舒服哂.
最近買左一支A16給仔仔,平價大光圈,我仔仔都好鍾意用.雖然此鏡跟我支17-40L有重複的感覺,
但大一級光圈就始終係大一級光圈,唔可以相提並論.
G9呢部機,我其實都好鍾意,但係有次仔仔同女朋友去影聖誕燈飾,比人從背囊偷左.
結果就買返部SX1 IS USM頂檔.而個G9潛水殼,就長埋防潮櫃,等佢獨自哭泣.
5D MKII,原本我真係好想買,去左旺角百老匯訂左貨,結果等左兩個月都未有貨.
到佢有貨時,我已買了SX1 IS USM,原先貪5D MKII可以有2,110萬像素,又可以拍1080P短片.
但係我部SX1 IS USM亦可以拍到1080I短片,況且原來自己影相的時候好少拍短片,
5D MKII作用和吸引力大減.
夜闌人靜,撫心自問,高像素是否自己所需?我又唔鍾意裁相,又唔鍾意曬大相,最多都係曬4R或者4D.
反而我影相就喜愛高速,對焦要快,構圖要快,用5D用M MODE,快門和光圈可以很快調校到,話影就影,不愛拖泥帶水.
1系機,是我最終的理想,1DS MKIII,睇到個價錢都唔會買,雖然我真係好鍾意FF,但係五萬幾???點買得落手.
反而1D MKIII,就令我思前想後,此機現金價約莫$29,800元都算合理.
5D MKII淨機身都要約二萬,重要另外買直度,買多塊電池合計差不多又二千元.
其實5D MKII連直度跟1D MKIII相差只不過係幾千元.
5D和5D MKII都只係9個自動對焦點及6個輔助自動對焦點.
而1D MKIII和1DS MKIII係有19個自動對焦點(十字型)及26個輔助對焦點 (共45點).
而防塵能力,1D MKIII絕對比5D MKII高好多.
防水滴能力,1系絕對係全天候機.
1D MKIII的100%觀景器,明亮度又好,但個LCD只得23萬點.
5D MKII的98%觀景器,個LCD有92萬點.
1系的影像類型是14 BIT,我部5D係12 BIT,而部5D MKII已改用14 BIT.
高ISO,付出的代價是少了層次感,等價交換而已.
但1系的DIGIC 3雙處理器,處理數據能力應該比5D MKII的DIGIC 4單處理器高.
但係1D MKIII的1.3X,對用慣FF的我,又有點左右為難的感覺.
所以,我而家都係為左升級而煩惱不休!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Obi-Wan]

fish30d

My photograph teachers in 1980's said

"you can be addicted to photography, but you must not be addicted to equipment because equipment can be obsolete, but your photography skill will not"

"Just like your girl friend, never give up the equipment you are using unless you fully know its strong points and weak points"