[ching_laputa]

各位師兄師姐，你地好~~~
我係用400d，有一支kit set lens 18-55mm 同埋一支 ef 50mm f/1.8 ii 鏡，已經用左好奈(但係技術就未見有所提升)....
用左呢兩支鏡咁奈，覺得18-55mm 呢支鏡麻麻地，而且今年會去旅行，所以打算添置一支天涯鏡，我依家諗緊揀 18-200mm 好定24-105mm 好，前者價錢較平，range 大，廣角相對好d，後者唔洗講la，一個紅圈已經show到佢貴d la，而且會影得靚d，但係加落我支400d到就一d 都唔廣角....好似影境唔係太實用....但係我又俾佢個 L 吸引住同埋上ff機都仲用到~~~
可惜價錢對我泥講又係一個重要因素!!!所以依家苦惱緊買邊支好...希望大家可以俾d 意見同埋幫我分析一下~~~thx~~~
p.s. 其實我完全無留意外廠鏡，因為我唔係太認識其他牌子同埋佢地嘅質素~~~~

[dainty]

樓主,

建議不要買EFS 18-200 IS, 價錢太貴, 大約$5000. (帶天涯鏡, 不如帶G10 or DC)

1) 如有錢, 買EF 24-105L IS. ( 新貨$7580, 2手$6200, 價錢貴, 但有L鏡質素 !
2) 如無錢, 可考慮 EF 28-135 IS (新$3990, 2手$2700)

再帶EFS18-55 KIT LEN 一起去旅行, 已足夠.

[rainbow179]

一齊研究...............但買枝 55-250 會唔會岩 o的??? $1680

[rickwok]

55-250平靚正

[Sam1983]

18-200,價錢咁都叫貴......鏡頭新出冇耐價錢都係咁左下了,出面賣這支鏡$5000都唔駛......

24-105,行貨都要$7000幾......不過"L鏡"只是個名牌,唔一定100%擔保你影相一定好有優勢

[plcleung]

全新行貨 18-200 can be sold seperately at $4,200 from the kit set of 50D in Tsimshatsui 忠X. I tried this lens in the Canon showroom and found that this lens produces sharp and vivid images at high speed. It can gives four stops IS function. It deserves to buy this lens at about $4K.

[ching_laputa]

多謝各位意見，
to: plcleung 真係有咁既事???如果係about $4k 我都幾ok呢個價$，但係間野係賣行貨???信唔信得過???確實位置係邊ga???(請原諒我太多問題)thxthxthx~~~~
我想問埋大家多唔多用副廠鏡ga???
因為我多數都留意原廠鏡，無乜留意副廠鏡。我淨係知道副廠鏡係平d，但係quality 就唔知掂唔掂，而且副廠鏡用落canon 機會唔會有d function 會差左???thx~~~

[dainty]

樓主,

其實副廠鏡用在canon body是無問題 (canon mount).
可以介紹3支大光圈副廠鏡給你參考:
1) Tokina 28-80 f2.8 (第5代鏡, 已停產, 一定要在2手市場, 才可以買到, 多數鏡主都會keep住,好小放售, 支鏡好Sharp, 如收到f4, 仲更加sharp到可以數眼睫毛)
2) Tamron 28-75 f2.8 (多數人叫A09, 3支鏡中最輕的一支, f4以上好sharp)
3) Sigma 28-70 f2.8 (要用82mm uv filter, f4以上好sharp)

以上3支鏡都可以用在FF機或APSC機上.
3支鏡我都用過, 個人覺得TOKINIA 28-80 是最SHARP (個人意見).

但有錢, 最好買原廠EF 24-70L f2.8 or EF 24-105L f4 !!!

[Obi-Wan]

18-200 IS ok sharp for daily use, I use it happily with my 50D even though I have other L lenses

[ching_laputa]

thx 各位師兄，認識左多好多鏡~~~
多口想問句各位師兄師姐最常用邊支鏡???

[ion78]

建議買18-200mm, F/4.0 OR 2.8, IS, USM. 24-105mm 係靚, 不過wide又唔夠WIDE, ZOOM又唔夠遠. X1.6 CROP FACTOR後只是38X168mm...有D到喉唔到肺咁...個人意見only.

[Millerso]

It based on your choice.....

1)budget
2)picture quality
3)zoom range

I am using 24-105 F4L on my 50D....So far so good....If 18-200 is $4xxx, I rather pay more for 24-105...The RED "L" circle is mainly reason....HAHA...

[Thomas1]

L 一定好過 普通kit

4千幾 買18-200!!!! not gd la

消費用下腦,問多d,想多d, 錢使得好d嗎
有好多好組合

(1)a16 加 55--250 is...... save money , ok 一般
(2) 17-40 L ....gd quality
(3)24-105 L ...gd quality
(4) SIGMA 18-125 加 50.1.8 定焦(可以選有os ga)... save money
(5)Tamron 17-35 加 50 1.4 定焦
(5)Tamron 17-35 加 55--250 is

仲有好多好組合 ga

你去travel .先買18-200.你好多travel ?

以上質素全好過kit 18-200, 如用L 有型有質素

[老叟]

想要影靚相,就要買小三元囉

[Koffy]

24-105不能算是天涯鏡吧, 用在APSC上實在有點兩頭唔到岸的感覺. 若是旅行只帶一支鏡, 可能不及18-200 實際, 而且後者亦較輕 (雖然不是差好遠...)

我自己最常用17-55, 不過如果去旅行都會揀帶18-200.