[火Ken]

小弟用5D mark II，用緊支24-70L，上次去西貢行山，行左四五個鐘攞住佢.........真係想死[之前去外地旅行時唔太覺佢重]，小弟終於明白天涯鏡嘅好處！現在想入手一支輕便嘅鏡，但我d朋友叫我入支二手24-105L 二手約$6XXX或者Tamron 28-75mm(A09)二手約$2XXX，但我又覺得好似幾浪費，因為我唔會放支24-70L，再加上同時擁有同range嘅Lens又加上$6XXX，計落好似好不化算咁，同埋我太太新手玩單反佢鍾意映人唔映風景，所以range對佢已經不重要，但佢要支鏡要輕，所以我咪想入支可同時用FF及 APS-C用嘅鏡囉！！希望C hing們比d 意見仔我；我呢兩日上過網睇過.........C hing有無人用過或者用緊下面幾支鏡呢？？
1) Canon EF 28-135mm f3.5-5.6 IS USM 540g
2) Canon EF 28-200mm f/3.5-5.6 USM 500g
3) Tamron AF 28-200mm F3.8-5.6 XR Di Aspherical [IF] Macro (A31) 354g
呢幾支鏡我見d價錢都係約$2XXX幾，我其實見到都幾ok！希望C hing比d 意見我，感激！

[checkylam]

我之前都有ching你呢個問題,我用50d+24-70,仲要帶多枝小白is添,攪到條頸痛到不得了,後來用左減壓帶就ok晒了,係mount左枝小白is時,頭重尾輕,要隻左手扶鏡。

[fu220]

師兄如果主要影人會考慮定焦鏡嗎？
30-50mm影人一流

[火Ken]

其實每次旅行我都會带三支鏡17-40L，24-70L，小小白IS，原因去旅行我好鍾意映風景，黃昏就會轉用24-70L，咁多旅行都ok得。點知今次西貢行山明白到天涯鏡嘅好處..............

[火Ken]

定焦我有，但我想要多支行山用，要不太重[因為我太太可以用]

[Obi-Wan]

火Ken, i have these three lens before in the 199X, the 28-135 is the best among these 3, the tamron was the worst, I still keep this because can't sell as some coating has been damaged

conclusion, all are cheap quality leness, the 28-200 EF is the worst canon zoom I've ever owned

[hcdo]

i think sigma 18-200 with os is not bad for hiking.try to have some more comment from others.

[火Ken]

Obi-wan c hing~ 我英文比較差，我唔知有無誤解，你應為Tamron 28-200mm係最差..........Canon 28-135mm係中間？？28-200mm 係ok？？？唔通真係買24-105IS？價錢同佢重量都要考慮，但我情意結係Tokina.........咁樣你仲有無其他推介？？

[火Ken]

hcdo c hing~ 支鏡想用响FF機，18-200 DC好似用不到 >_<

[hcdo]

sorry,i miss this point.

[火Ken]

不打緊~你都係真心比意見我啫！但你講果支係咪咩OC HSM都無$1XXX 頭左右？？我太太都可以用嘅..........質素如何？？

[cfmak]

i am talking abount the sigma 18-200mm f.3.5-6.3 dc os hsm.2nd hand price around 2000-plus.maybe u ask mr.obi-wan's opinion.

[Obi-Wan]

火Ken
最差28-200 tamron

EF 28200係我用過最水皮嘅Canon出品，多年前$2780 入咗之後極速$2000放咗，之後入咗tamron, 點之仲衰！

[火Ken]

Obi-Wan c hing~ 之後入咗tamron, 點之仲衰！<<<< Hahahaha..........咁除左Canon 28-135 IS 外無其他可取啦！最衰我有24-70L，如果唔係都會入支二手24-105L玩下！

[火Ken]

但好似EF 28-105mm 2代都幾ok 幾經濟！！