[火Ken]

我今日收工無聊去左旺角朋友間鋪頭試新鏡，因為無帶我部5D2，所以用左太太用既型號500D試過支全新 Canon EF 28-135mmIS[$3480]，24-85mm[$2580]，28-105mm[停产無貨無得試]，24-85mm個range不太好，加上果支係次貨不會出售.....但 EF 28-135mm 真係對焦出奇地快.....至於質數我就分不出，跟住上左星際d二手店度睇....需然有28-105[$1150] 但我無試過，因為比一支鏡吸引Tokina AT-X 242 AF AF 24-200mm f/3.5-5.6，試過都ok但好行重！我其實Tokina都ok，但考慮期間佢見到話我知zoom出部分有二條1cm裂痕，佢需然話無問題，但都好好人咁叫我考慮下先！其實range係超perfect！但裂痕加重量690g.....令我心大心細，我今次揀呢個range 24 or 28-XXXmm 係想同我老婆部500D 共用，所以好想好想，但無奈......呢加得番支二手 Canon EF 28-105mm[未試過] and EF 28-135mm[試過，輕，zoom快]，我揀邊支好呢？前者平但未試過，後者我會入二手價$2000-2200[無保養]，其實相差只係$1000，所以我都想你比d意見！兩支揀其一：
1）Canon EF 28-135mm f3.5-5.6 IS USM
2）Canon EF 28-105mm f3.5-4.5 II USM
麻煩咁多位C hing先~

[chris053]

1)

[andy413hk]

1) X2

[chris053]

補充:
有$ 就梗係1 好LA
又有IS,焦距又較長,
不過枝鏡都成540g wo ,洗唔洗帶埋你另一半去試下重唔重先~ ~"

[火Ken]

其實我比個支17-40L佢用，佢都ok~ 係夜景10張在3~4張手震，要推高ISO就無問題，有時女人都幾特別，我太太鍾意玩人像，又加上我行山用支24-70L超重！！所以咪揀支24 or 28-XXXmm lens 囉！

[chris053]

鍾意玩人像點解唔買枝f2.8呢??

[chris053]

Sigma 17-70mm F2.8-4.5 DC MACRO HSM (我都未用過,唔知質素)

[chris053]

如果有$的話,我買簡24-105tim!!
雖然f4 ,但此終係恆定光圈,
雖然重小小,但係有4級IS補番曬~
雖然2手會貴你1) 果枝3千幾,但係一定值得!!

[fish30d]

If you already have 5D2, then 24-105L is your best choice

[Marksman01]

I bought a 28-135 used from a DC Fever Ching (if I recall correctly who is canonball Ching, heehee)

The PQ is excellent, nearly on par with 24-105 especially the resolution, with the IS and USM the handling is also excellent in AF tracking and in dark condition. I bought this lens for my 5D2 for a business trip to U.S. I just don't need a reduntant range to the 24-70 so I sold it after use.

[火Ken]

我已經擁有24-70L，行山覺得佢太重！！24-105L好似有點浪費同重[太太認為]，SIGMA 17-70mm 我5D mark II 用不著..........28-135mm 二手價幾ok，太太都用過我支17-40L，佢都ok話好用，所以我決定28-135mm！多謝C hing們意見！

[cy001]

Canon EF 28-135mm f3.5-5.6 IS USM is a old len, the IS is not 4xIS. will u consider 18-135mm IS USM?

[火Ken]

cyoo1 c hing~ 用响 5D Mark II 度........

[cy001]

no idea, i haven't used both of them before.

[火Ken]

我二手入左Canon EF 28-135mm f3.5-5.6 IS USM 啦！