[kh-1]

小弟喜歡影人像和人像+境，所以入了支S50.4，基本上對支S50.4無不滿，影人絕對交到貨，但小弟用緊550D，想影下人像+景時就好難用，所以想入支標準鏡代替。

因為小弟真係無銀，所以一定要放支S50.4先有錢入支好少少的標準鏡！心目中有以下3支，都係5千左右，合乎預算：

1.17-40L（絕對係紅圈虛榮，未用過紅圈此終想試，無左IS，只得F4，）

2.24-105L（有IS、無Wide，F4）

3.S17-50 OS HSM (新鏡，有OS，有HSM，budget之內）

想問下各位C-hing，影人計邊支會最接近S50.4的質素？

[ks chung]

我都是主力影人. 我無你哪支鏡, 但看過很多評論都好好. 更有人(包括大鋪sale都稱這支為50.4鏡王. 我自己都心思思想放咗支C50.4. 入手這鏡!!! 你講嗰3支變焦鏡根本就無得flight. 又要平,真是無得選???

[look_yau]

一係儲錢，一係企後啲

[kh-1]

Ching講的小弟也明白，但無銀就要放棄質素，影相此終都係影下人和物，如果影唔到，有質素都無用！所以小弟想過後，都係選擇影到，放棄質素，係有限既金錢下，放棄最少的質素（小弟都知大貪左）

補充：支24-105mm會買2手，所以合乎預算！

[stanley1981]

S50.4 雖然係用得辛苦d, 但係一支好鏡黎, 如果唔想買鏡, 可以練下自己如何用s50 1.4取景, 都唔錯ga....

我都有A16, 14~40, 小小白, SIGMA 30 1.4, 116, 最常用都係30 1.4

[rankinelo]

kh-1 CHing,

I have both S50.4 and C24-105L... the bokeh of 24-105 can never reach the level of S50.4... and the coloring tone is different.

The best replacement of your S50.4 should be C17-55...

[ks chung]

收到! 亦明白C-Hing的難處!
1) 就算你放支s50.4出去, 亦要補唔小$$才可以買到支24-105喎??? 這個補價足夠你買支A16玩. 哪支鏡亦唔錯!!
2) 因你用ASP-C機, 24mmX1.5先至到35mm効果. 所以24-105要來影人+影, 好似唔多夠wide. 可能要考慮支17-40 or A16??

[SleepingIII]

17-55

[rankinelo]

kh-1 CHing,

Just 1 more thing,
>>2.24-105L（有IS、無Wide，F4）
The IS has 3-stop IS only. The difference of aperture for F1.4 and F4 is 3 stop. That means you won't gain any shutter speed with 24-105L

If you buy 24-105L, then you should go to 17-55... otherwise maybe you can go to A16 as suggested by ks chung CHing...

[hunter21]

唔驚走焦就買SIGMA 24-70 f2.8 全新約6000,最合乎你既要求.

17-40L-光圈細,焦距短

24-105-一樣光圈細加無WIDE.

S17-50-買得呢友不如比多少少買SIGMA 24-70 F2.8.

550D既話最有錢當然買原廠17-55 F2.8.點都好過17-40L同24-105.

[s82011190]

A16係唔錯選擇，如果要影嘅唔係小朋友或寵物，唔會走來走去A16係ok嘅，點解？因為A16對焦真係比較慢。

[lsammy]

Canon EF 28mm f/1.8 USM $3800
Canon EF 24mm f/2.8 $2800

玩開定焦好難轉
買多支定焦好過

[kh-1]

師兄所言甚是，只怪當初誤交定焦毒友！

[kh-1]

其實A16質素係唔錯，價錢又OK！買佢就唔使放S50.4！

[MDLP]

Buy C15-85 @$5600
good range x1.6 = 24-136
good PQ (better than 17-40)