After read the comments for this 小水珠s , I have the following feeling.



Hey all,



I'm new in this web. Basically, I agreed with what "micromax" mentioned below, but something want to seek yours opinions. In my point of view, photographic has 2 aims, 1. is for art, 2. is for record. For art, we will use our imagination to "create" the photo, it means it's a thing for present our thinking, out feeling, so, we just need people to understand it, to feel it, not matter how we change the structure in the pic. For record, it means it's like a dialog or a book, to record what the world is look like, what is the amazing part in our life. Of course there is grey area. So, it's really depends on yours intention. If he just want to show his pic's beauty, no doubt, it's prefect for 小水珠s or he wants to record how amazing of the nature, it's prefect again if it's real. Regarding the 後制作, I think almost 99% of the pics are having this. But if we think clearly, those 爆光不足的更正等等, all of this effects will not change the physical elements in the pic. For the conculsion, I believe for both art or record need 後制作, but for Art, we can change everything in the pic to match our presentation. But for record, we can't change the elements in the pics, on the other hand, we have to try our best to keep it. Imagine if those pics for historical/science records are false, it's a huge impact to us and our next generation.



I hope micromax don't mind I have this conculsion.





review from micromax

其實不用這麼固執, 一定要找出真偽, 若是假的, 靚咪得囉! 在以前未有數碼相機時, 那些攝影佬都有做後期制作, 那些佳作拿奬的作品多半是有後制作的, 什麼重叠菲林, 什麼彩色菲林黑白沖曬, 什麼爆光不足的更正等等, 全算是後期制作, 只是那時要做制作不是一件易事, 所以人們通常只有欣賞, 如今用了什麼PS, 3D等, 要改相並不是難事, 所以人們便覺得有點後期制作是不好了. 其實有誰夠膽說自己的照片能沒有後期制作, 調調光暗色調不是後期制作嗎?! 很多DC出廠時都把相機調暗一點以求稍爆光不足(話怕爆光過度, 無得求, NIKON廠都這樣說), 若我們不調調, 怎麼可以見人. 還有若你沒有改相, 你拿去沖曬店, 為何同一張相,一些店沖得好, 色調光暗好好, 一些很差勁, 主要原因不是那部沖相機有問題, 只是那個沖曬員的執相能力不好, 這樣你們的相片不是又給沖曬員代勞做了後期制作, 只是大家沒有察覺.



我絕對相信作者, 因為若是假的, 他不用拿証明, 簡簡單單認了便成, 不用把相片發表區變成討論區, 他這樣的做法, 純是有怨情, 以心理學的角度推算, 他的動機是可以使人相信他的作品是真的.



若大家還覺得他的作品因為"假"才上到今日之選, 那麼大可以用什麼3D, PS做做看, 做一張同類照片跟它爭奪, 讓他不能獨美吧!



各位請恕我有感而發! 自數碼相機面世以來, 很多人都評論數碼化的後期制作, 本人覺得那只是一班傳統相機佬不接受現實, 怕多年的攝影技術給人取代, 不進步的表現, 現時那一間影樓, 拍婚紗的那有不用數碼的後期制作. 若各位還是覺得後期數碼制作不好, 那麼你買數碼相機干嗎?! 只是為了即影即有?! 若是這樣, 我才不信. 若再現在還沒有後期制作的, 只是不懂吧!



Fuwing8, 雖然我跟你素未謀面, 但我相信相是真的! micromax

2003-09-02 08:04:09